Jesus followers@Tokyo Baptist Church & abolitionists of human trafficking in Japan & the world

Showing posts with label Law. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Law. Show all posts

Thursday, 1 February 2018

Modern Slavery: An Updated Look at Japan

Photo by Anabel F. Zamora on Unsplash

Japan is a place where modern slavery can happen out of sight and many kinds of people are enslaved today: Japanese, foreigners, children, adults, women, and men. Many of these individuals are in sex trafficking and forced labor situations. It may be surprising to see the depth of this problem in Japan.  

In the latest analysis by the 2017 Trafficking in Persons Report, Japan has been put into the Tier 2. This means that, according to the standards of the Trafficking Victims Protection Act (TVPA), Japan does not fully reach the standards for working toward eliminating human trafficking, but is making strides to do so. The government has recently passed legislation to protect people, but there are many that are not being protected.  For example, there are far too many cases of child pornography, abuse of foreign technical intern trainees, and other forms of sex trafficking and forced labor. Many of these people are tricked into giving unwanted services, such as posing for porn rather than modeling or being trapped in a low paying job and poorly treated rather than studying.

According to the report, Japan is convicting and prosecuting more traffickers, but there are still areas where Japan falls short of the TVPA Standards. This report suggests recommendations for Japan and addresses Prosecution, Protection, and Prevention.  Praise the Lord that efforts are being made to stop and prevent these kinds of atrocities, but Japan has been in Tier 2 for over 16 years and there are many improvements that need to be made.

If you would like to know more about this in Japanese please view the PDF「人身取引」と「女性に対する暴力」をなくすために.

Please pray for more laws to be passed to protect more people.


Wednesday, 22 June 2016

UK’s anti-trafficking law on businesses

From 29 October 2015, businesses with a commercial presence in the UK and a worldwide turnover in excess of £36 million must report annually on the steps they have taken to ensure that their businesses and supply chains are free of slavery and human trafficking.

The UK Modern Slavery Act consolidates the law relating to slavery, servitude, forced and compulsory labor and human trafficking. These offences now carry a maximum penalty of life imprisonment. The Act comes at a time of increasing concern regarding slavery and human trafficking affecting global supply chains, particularly in Asia.
This is a positive development and hopefully other countries will follow suit (Praise God!). The law tackles the issue head on, it is easily understandable to businesses and it carries the full force of the law (unlike some international conventions or international business focused groups which seek sustainability and good business practices but are private and self-regulating and so deal out meaningful penalties).
The law should cause businesses to investigate their supply chains to ensure that it has no slavery and human trafficking, and then prepare a slavery and human trafficking statement each financial year which must be publicly available, written in simple language. Organizations that take no steps must say so in the statement and explain why they have not done so.  
There are no civil or criminal penalties for failing to report, but the courts may compel the offending business to publish the statement. The greatest damage for any offending or non-reporting business is negative press and bad reputation, which can seriously change perceptions on the brand of a company.
It means that abolitionists and the wide public can exercise their consumer choices with greater confidence that they are not contributing to slavery and human trafficking by buying products and services provided by certain businesses which positively say that their global supply chain are free of slavery and human trafficking.

Sunday, 19 June 2016

Japan panel calls for heavy regulation of JK

As reported in Japan Times, a panel set up by the Tokyo Metropolitan Police Department recently called for tightening the regulations governing dating services i.e josh kosei or “JK” offered by teenage schoolgirls, including the introduction of penalties, with the aim of protecting such minors from harm.

JK drew international criticism, with Maud de Boer-Buquicchio, U.N. special rapporteur on the sale of children, child prostitution and child pornography, urging the Japanese government in March to ban such practices, saying it could lead to the sexual exploitation of children. Click here and here for earlier posts on her findings.

The police have no powers to conduct any on-site inspections because such businesses are not subject to the sex industry law. The report pointed out the need for new regulatory statutes to tackle the issue. In response, the police will consider making a new ordinance or revising the existing one.

The panel said that attracting customers with girls aged 17 or younger and soliciting boys and girls as customers and employees should be prohibited.

According to a survey by Tokyo police covering 423 girls between 15 and 18 in March, 10% of respondents said they knew someone involved in the JK business, while around half of them expected the number of high school girls joining such businesses to rise. Tokyo police detected 174 locations providing JK business services within Tokyo as of January, up 42 from June last year.

This is a welcomed development (Praise God!). Last year, activist Yumeno Nito, 25, founder of Colabo, a Tokyo-based support group for marginalized teen girls, called on Prime Minister Abe to initiate efforts to eradicate the problem of sex trafficking involving high school girls in Japan, describing the nation as too indifferent toward curbing child prostitution (click here for Japan Times article). Miss Nito believed that the situation surrounding the part-time job industry and sexual exploitation of joshi kosei (high school girls) had gotten worse. At the time she said, is that the central government apparently is not interested in stamping out such commercial sex involving teens. She said:

“Japan significantly lags behind other industrialized nations in cracking down on child prostitution. Instead, the government downright ignores what is happening to those girls,” .

Furthermore, she believes the misguided assumption that the girls, not the traffickers or customers, are to blame runs deep within the government and society. She said:
“But this thinking does not solve the problem. The society instead must think how to change the background or environment of the girls by providing them with care and support so they don’t find themselves in these businesses”

Monday, 13 June 2016

United Nations Human Rights Council Statement on Japan

As noted on this earlier post, at the 31st session of the Human Rights Council in March 2016, the Special Rapporteur Maud de Boer-Buquicchio presented her thematic report on tackling the demand for the sexual exploitation of children.   

Below is her speech based on her short visit to Japan (click here for her full statement, a summary in two parts of her interactive dialogue with Member States, and a summary of the side event organized on this subject. A summary of her recommendations can be found here). Click below to read her speech.


Tuesday, 25 August 2015

Laws aimed at protecting prostitutes may endanger human trafficking victims

A previous post posed: "Should Sweden's approach to prostitution be adopted everywhere?" That post identified the dangers of a world which legalised prostitution, which is the model adopted in Sweden and now in other countries.

Recently in Dublin Amnesty International announced its plan to support a policy that calls for the decriminalisation of the sex trade. This means that pimps, brothel and buyers of sex can continue to go about their business unchecked.

Probably well intentioned, the plan comes from a view that the multi-billion dollar sex trade is a legitimate business that needs to protect sex workers (just like any people in danger or facing injustice) by supporting the legalisation of prostitution. In essence, by legalising it, the government could also (hope to) regulate. It is a big "could", and furthermore it comes from a hope that legalising prostitution would the rights and welfare of sex workers. But in reality, this policy will worsen the plight of child sex trafficking victims. Amnesty International's resolution can be found here. To be clear, Amnesty International opposes human trafficking.

Previously featured in the Spotlight series, Operation Underground Railroad (known as O.U.R), is an organization dedicated to rescuing children from sex slavery. Its CEO, Tim Ballard recently shared his passionate views about Amnesty International's plans, which can be found here. Below is an excerpt, but a good read of the entire article is recommended:
"Let’s break down this train of logic. In Amnesty’s resolution, “Draft Policy on Sex Work,” it argues that pimps and johns should be free from government interference and be permitted to exercise their autonomy. The argument is based on the idea that those being sold want to be sold, because it is their chosen profession. While certainly some have made that choice the idea dangerously ignores the backstory of those who “choose” prostitution. We must consider how many of these men and women were enslaved in the sex industry as children and now as adults who don’t see any other option. Is that a choice? We must also consider the enormous number of prostitutes that suffer from post-traumatic stress disorder and numerous sexually transmitted diseases. We must also acknowledge statistical confirmation that a disproportionate number of prostitutes are survivors of rape and child sex abuse. Do we really think that any of these men or women happily dreamed as children that one day they would grow up to sell their bodies for sex?"

Friday, 10 April 2015

Companies contacted to report on human trafficking in their supply chains

On April 1, 2015, the Attorney-General's office of California sent letters to companies it believes may be subject to the Transparency in Supply Chains Act 2010.

What is this all about? Under the Act, retailers or manufacturers doing business in California with annual worldwide gross receipts that exceed $100,000,000 must disclose what efforts they take to eradicate slavery and human trafficking from their supply chains. This disclosure must be accessible from an easily understood link on business' homepage.

The Act does not require that a company undertake any specific efforts, rather the purpose of the law is to make companies disclose information to the public. Specifically, the Act requires the company to disclose what, if anything, it does in specific areas, such as whether human trafficking is evaluated in their product supply chain and whether employees who have direct responsibility for supply chains to receive training.

Like many human trafficking laws, the Act is focussed on the demand side of human trafficking, and yet unlike many human trafficking laws, it focusses on businesses, the potential buyers of products made with raw materials harvested or processed by forced labour. This is a good development and also reflects a growing awareness and acceptance amongst (especially large multinational) corporations to take responsibility about human rights violations in the operation of their businesses.

Wednesday, 25 March 2015

【Updated 22 May 2015】 Key U.S anti-human trafficking law hits a road block

[Updated: Praise God! On 19 May, the U.S. House of Representatives passed the Justice for Victims of Trafficking Act of 2015. If signed by the President, the bill would create a domestic fund for victims of child sex trafficking from fines levied against traffickers. Fines collected from traffickers will bolster local law enforcement training and capabilities, among other capacity building measures. The final bill still denies funding for abortion services to underage victims of sex trafficking.]

In a blog post last year "The Report Card on US anti human trafficking lawmakers", it was noted that several US anti-trafficking bills were published for consideration by US lawmarkers. Many expected some (but not all) of those bills to pass in 2015, but a recent development is threatening to derail the passing of a key anti-trafficking bill highlighting the complexities of human trafficking and law making.

Read here and here for more. Click below to read an excerpt for the second link.

Is a vote for human trafficking laws a vote for abortion?
 
Keep the lawmakers in the US and Japan in your prayers

WATCH THIS SPACE: Human Trafficking Courts (it is now a reality)

Read the following article "Sex Trafficking and the Carceral State"  here on End Slavery Now's website to learn about an innovative way in which the court system in New York is developing to give human trafficking victims arrested in the course of prostitution a choice to get out; a chance to break the cycle of exploitation by agreeing to be counselled instead of being treated as a lawbreaker. 

A strong feature of this innovation is that it adopts a starting viewpoint that sex work is ineherently unlawful, which stands directly in opposition to those who wish to legalise prostitution around the world, and is a victim focussed based approach to legal reform which other legal systems in other countries (or states) have been unable to do (click to read previous blog post).

Click below for a synopsis of the article:

Friday, 20 March 2015

Why the victory in a recent US human trafficking court case is important

After 7 years in court, a federal jury this February awarded $14 million damages to five Indian guest workers who were defrauded and exploited in a labour trafficking scheme conducted by a marine services company, an immigration lawyer and an Indian labour recruiter who lured hundreds of foreign workers to a Mississippi shipyard with false promises of permanent U.S. residency.

There is a common perception that human trafficking mainly occurs in developing countries with no rule of law, corrupt officials and law enforcement officers, abject poverty and carried out by criminals and ganglords. None of these factors were present in this court case.

In the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina, Signal used the U.S. government’s "H-2B" guest worker program to import nearly 500 men from India to work as welders, pipefitters and in other positions to repair damaged oil rigs and related facilities. The workers each paid the labour recruiters and a lawyer between $10,000 and $20,000 or more in recruitment fees and other costs after recruiters promised good jobs, green cards and permanent U.S. residency for them and their families. Most sold property or plunged their families deeply into debt to pay the fees.

When the men arrived at Signal shipyards in Pascagoula, Mississippi, beginning in 2006, they discovered that they wouldn’t receive the green cards or permanent residency that had been promised. Signal also forced them each to pay $1,050 a month to live in isolated, guarded labour camps where as many as 24 men shared a space the size of a double-wide trailer. The workers were underfed, lived in unhygenic conditions, forced to work around the clock and of what they earned, fees were deducted leaving them with very little (or nothing). None of Signal’s non-Indian workers were required to live in the company housing.

It is estimated that Signal saved more than $8 million in labour costs by hiring the Indian workers at below-market wages.

Why is this a case of (labour) human trafficking?  Why do you need to know about this case?

Tuesday, 18 November 2014

Should Sweden's approach to prostitution be adopted everywhere?

Canada is the latest country to adopt the “Nordic approach” to prostitution laws, introduced in Sweden in 1999. If the Bill is passed, the purchase of sex will be illegal, but not the sale of sex will be legal.

It is reported that the Nordic approach has been successful in reducing prostitution in Sweden as well as other exploitative practices such as strip clubs. Norway, Iceland, France, and South Korea have followed Sweden's example.

What has this got to do with human trafficking? Commentators believe that Sweden's change to its prostitution laws conincided and contributed to Sweden having the lowest human trafficking in Europe. Its success is attributed to eradicating the demand for prostitution and related activities. 

Monday, 4 August 2014

The report card on US anti-human trafficking law makers

Infographic showing hotspots of reported HT cases in the US
In May this year, the U.S House of Representatives passed 5 bills (i.e. not yet laws) focussed on anti-human trafficking. The contents of those bills are summarised here, and includes links to articles in the New York Times and TIMES magazine.  The Senate must pass these bills before they take the effect of law. The text of the bills and the estimated liklihood of those bills being passed can be accessed here.

Polaris, a NGO based in the U.S that works to combat and prevent modern day slavery and human trafficking, has responded with their assessment of the bills (which can be found here) with mixed views on the bills.

Friday, 1 August 2014

Human Trafficking Legal Database

For more than 2 years, the United Nations (via its United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime section) has made available an online resource to increase the visibility of successful human trafficking prosecutions around the world. 

Follow this link to obtain access to summaries and court documents contained in the UNODC Human Trafficking Case Law Database. As well as being a valuable resource for law practitioners such as judges and prosecutors who are at the front line of the legal battle, it gives insight into the approaches taken in different countries around the world in tackling human trafficking.

Tuesday, 24 June 2014

U.S puts pressure on legalised prostitution

In addition to the Diet vote in Japan on 22 June, let's keep this U.S Bill in prayer also:
"Rep. Randy Hultgren, an Illinois Republican in his first term in Congress, has introduced legislation designed to combat sex trafficking by putting diplomatic pressure on countries with legal prostitution. The bill would make countries' policies on prostitution a factor in their access to foreign aid money from the U.S. -- and it could affect American relationships with countries where prostitution is legal, such as Germany, Mexico and Greece.

Hultgren's case for that change is based on the premise that legal prostitution fosters human trafficking. 
 
“If you have prostitution in your area, then you have child prostitution in your area,” he said. “When nations have government-sanctioned prostitution, that is a major factor to sex slavery.”

More at this link. 

Friday, 20 June 2014

Japan Outlaws Possession of Child Pornography

New York Times confirmed this development which occurred this Wednesday

"TOKYO — Yielding to years of pressure to fall in line with the rest of the developed world, Japan’s Parliament outlawed the possession of child pornography on Wednesday. But the new law left untouched the nation’s popular and sometimes sexually explicit manga comics as well as other portrayals of young girls as objects of sexual desire." 

Wednesday, 4 June 2014

Japan finally moving to ban child porn possession

Praise the Lord! It's not over though so join with us in prayer for the Diet vote on 22 June and for children who have fallen victim. From the Japan Times today:

"The Lower House Judicial Affairs Committee discussed a bill to expand the scope of the legislation Wednesday and was expected to send it on to the full chamber later in the day.
The Lower House is expected to swiftly pass the bill and move it to the Upper House for a vote before the current Diet session ends June 22."
For the full article, click here