Canada is the latest country to adopt the “Nordic approach” to prostitution laws, introduced in Sweden in 1999. If the Bill is passed, the purchase of sex will be illegal, but not the sale of sex will be legal.It is reported that the Nordic approach has been successful in reducing prostitution in Sweden as well as other exploitative practices such as strip clubs. Norway, Iceland, France, and South Korea have followed Sweden's example.
What has this got to do with human trafficking? Commentators believe that Sweden's change to its prostitution laws conincided and contributed to Sweden having the lowest human trafficking in Europe. Its success is attributed to eradicating the demand for prostitution and related activities.
If the Bill is passed as a law and the results in Sweden can be duplicated in Canada, it will be a welcomed triumph for victims of and abolitionists in the fight against sex trafficking. It should be remembered that the Swedish prostitution laws are complemented by strong enforcement by the police and health and rehabilitaiton aid programmes to help prostitutes leave sex work forever. Also, Sweden also has very strict anti-trafficking laws.
Side note: In contrast, the purchase and sale of sex for money is a criminal act in Japan, however reducing human trafficking and passing anti-trafficking laws in Japan remains challenging and much more needs to be done, as recognised by the U.N 2014 Trafficking in Persons Report. So, there is clearly more to it....
The wrinkle. The Bill is not supported by many Canadians and citizens of other countries in which the Nordic approach has been proposed. This issue is incredibly complex and there is a bigger picture from a spiritual perspective. The main detractors of the Bill belong to a segment of sex workers in Canada (which are not a small group) who believe they aren't victims and enter the sex trade as a legitimate means of employment and self support (which has been made much accessible in the Internet age) and they believe the Bill will take away their livelihood. Why they believe that is another topic altogether. Add to this other groups and activists who believe that criminalising any part of the sex trade will increase violence and rape (there is precedent for this in Canada) as prostitution will be pushed into darker recesses of the community making it hard to police and detect. There is a concern that prostitutes will become more dependent on pimps for business. Pimps (and traffickers) who are increasingly becoming bolder and sophisticated will need to be more covert, more underground. Now, imagine the same scenario for a victim of human trafficking whose main way of escape other than fleeing is being identified and helped (see also this post). Trafficked victims may be inadvertently worse off because of the Bill becoming a law.
The populist swell. Growing liberalism and moral relativism in society support the detractors of the Bill and now people around the world have begun suggesting that the solution might be to legalise prostitution (on both the buy and sell side) and heavily regulate it to ensure greater safety and other concerns. In short, the (growing) world view is that society might be "better off" if sex can be freely sold and bought between consensual individuals, unless it involves children and people coerced into the sex trade i.e. victims of sex trafficking. A win-win outcome.... right?
What does God think?
“I am the LORD, I do not change” (Malachi 3:6, NKJV)
God is unchanging. His standard is absolute, and does not bend to the circumstances, Yet, these issues, as complex as they seem to us, is not beyond God to understand, who in addition to being omniscient and sovereign is holy and righteous: “All His precepts are sure. They stand fast forever and ever” (Psalm 111:7, 8, NKJV)
If Christians around the world were to hold society to God's standard of holiness, would they be imposing their narrow minded morality on self determining individuals exercising their (in Canada's case, constitutional) rights? That might be a popular response, but the people criticising Christian for narrow mindedness are actually imposing their kind of morality on others. Many today believe that they are able—and that they have the right—to choose their own values,
“Woe to those who call evil good, and good evil; who put darkness for light, and light for darkness; who put bitter for sweet, and sweet for bitter!” (Isaiah 5:20).
God's word- the Bible - teaches that right and wrong, good and evil, are absolutes. They are ultimately defined by God. He has placed in the human heart a recognition of these absolutes—the conscience—that tells us right from wrong. And God promises to judge everyone on the basis of His absolute, eternal, unchangeable law. “Fear God and keep his commandments, for this is the whole duty of man. For God will bring every deed into judgment, including every secret thing, whether is it good or evil” (Ecclesiastes 12:13, 14, NIV)
What is the lesson here? Law reform alone will not and in many cases is not able to bring justice to sex trafficking victims and eradicate human trafficking. Japan is a good illustrative example of this. It is part of the solution, and so is strict enforcement of laws and rehabilitation, education and welfare services. How about spiritual reform in the hearts and minds of men and women instead- the victims and the perpetrators? And, rather than looking towards the written laws of men, as pursuers of justice for the victims of injustice, lets look to the laws created by God our creator and saviour, who desires complete holiness, and seek what He seeks in the things He calls us to do. Instead of viewing the bible through the eyes of society and popular opinion, lets remember to view and assess society through the eyes of the Bible. One day our Lord Jesus Christ will return and "He will wipe every tear from their eyes. There will be no more death' or mourning or crying or pain, for the old order of things has passed away." (Revelations 21:4, NIV). Lets work together with that in mind.
No comments:
Post a Comment