Jesus followers@Tokyo Baptist Church & abolitionists of human trafficking in Japan & the world

Friday, 20 March 2015

Why the victory in a recent US human trafficking court case is important

After 7 years in court, a federal jury this February awarded $14 million damages to five Indian guest workers who were defrauded and exploited in a labour trafficking scheme conducted by a marine services company, an immigration lawyer and an Indian labour recruiter who lured hundreds of foreign workers to a Mississippi shipyard with false promises of permanent U.S. residency.

There is a common perception that human trafficking mainly occurs in developing countries with no rule of law, corrupt officials and law enforcement officers, abject poverty and carried out by criminals and ganglords. None of these factors were present in this court case.

In the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina, Signal used the U.S. government’s "H-2B" guest worker program to import nearly 500 men from India to work as welders, pipefitters and in other positions to repair damaged oil rigs and related facilities. The workers each paid the labour recruiters and a lawyer between $10,000 and $20,000 or more in recruitment fees and other costs after recruiters promised good jobs, green cards and permanent U.S. residency for them and their families. Most sold property or plunged their families deeply into debt to pay the fees.

When the men arrived at Signal shipyards in Pascagoula, Mississippi, beginning in 2006, they discovered that they wouldn’t receive the green cards or permanent residency that had been promised. Signal also forced them each to pay $1,050 a month to live in isolated, guarded labour camps where as many as 24 men shared a space the size of a double-wide trailer. The workers were underfed, lived in unhygenic conditions, forced to work around the clock and of what they earned, fees were deducted leaving them with very little (or nothing). None of Signal’s non-Indian workers were required to live in the company housing.

It is estimated that Signal saved more than $8 million in labour costs by hiring the Indian workers at below-market wages.

Why is this a case of (labour) human trafficking?  Why do you need to know about this case?


Signal was charged with other US laws which were not related to human trafficking -however, what makes this a human trafficking case? Isn't this just a simple case of discrimination, poor and unsafe working conditions, abuse of human rights and labour exploitation? (there are many examples of these, e.g. Bangladesh) 

Firstly, the court decided that together, the H-2B visa status (which mean deportation if their employer decided to do so), the high debt, the poor conditions at the labour camp and the discriminatory treatment and abuse based on their race or nationality led the men to feel trapped- in this case, the workers were guarded and held in barbed wired compounds, but in addition, what was compelling in the prosecution was that the workers felt psychologically restrained.

Secondly, there was clear case of coercion (physically and psychologically) as well as fraud and deception, together with an abuse of power (from an employer who held all the cards), which are elements which need to be shown to show a case of human trafficking.
 
These workers felt that they could not leave if they wanted to because of the consequences of being fired or quitting (some of which was true e.g. like deportation, some which were a product of lies). When some men tried to find their own housing, Signal officials told them the “man camp” fee would still be deducted from their pay. Visitors were rarely allowed into the camps. Company employees searched workers’ belongings. Workers who complained were threatened with deportation – a disastrous prospect for those who mortgaged their futures to obtain the jobs.

Some takeaways
  • Interestingly, US authorities and law enforcement did not uncover what was happening at the Signal "man camps". Rather, the plight of the works were revealed  after a worker attempted suicide and workers were retaliated against for seeking information about their rights. It shows that human trafficking can happen right under people's noses, in broad daylight, and by seemingly "good" companies making job opportunities to those that desperately need them. Surprisingly, in a way the terms of the government's "H-2B" guest worker program unintentionally facilitated the human trafficking.

  • This court case was a joint effort of civil rights groups and pro-active law firms willing to bring pro bono civil suits on behalf of smaller groups of victims. A civil law suit typically results in a harsh fine. In contrast a criminal conviction leads to jail time, which is arguably a more fitting punishment. In this case, only a civil law suit decision was awarded (which is being appealed by Signal). Although no criminal charges have been laid (yet), civil litigation, especially of this nature, is rare because of the resources needed to fund a long and expensive court case. It is a rarity. Praise God that justice was served in the way it was served, and in the timing that it was served. 

  • The human trafficking laws around the world are not perfect. In countries where the rule of law is weak and/or there is the absence of laws or a justice system, it further imprisons victims of human trafficking. In this case however, the intent of the law prevailed, which reminds us that the law is "good if one uses it lawfully":
Now we know that the law is good, if one uses it lawfully, understanding this, that the law is not laid down for the just but for the lawless and disobedient, for the ungodly and sinners, for the unholy and profane, for those who strike their fathers and mothers, for murderers, the sexually immoral, men who practice homosexuality, enslavers, liars, perjurers, and whatever else is contrary to sound doctrine (1 Timothy 2:8-10, ESV)

For the most part, laws are not  by themselves evil - but it is the abuse of power of evil and sinful men and women (and the apathy of others) which creates conditions for sinners to use the law lawlessly, like engaging in corruption, conspiring with traffickers and turning the blind eye for personal gain, at the expense of the weak. The bible promises a day when all evil will be exposed, and all actions accounted for- the day of our Lord Jesus Christ's return. Let's continue to pray for that day to come, and also pray for the victims of human trafficking, that they will not only be rescued, but also saved and join with us in looking forward to the return of our Lord Jesus Christ.
"God is just: He will pay back trouble to those who trouble you and give relief to you who are troubled, and to us as well. This will happen when the Lord Jesus is revealed from heaven in blazing fire with his powerful angels" (2 Thessalonians 1:6-7, NIV)

No comments:

Post a Comment