
This is a 2 part series on fair trade. Part 1 addresses whether fair trade is making a difference and Part 2 contains suggestions on how you can participate.
(The term “fair trade” when used in this article refers to the model of trade which pays sustainable prices to workers and producers of goods, and not any specific organization or goods which are permitted to use certain labels, like “Fairtrade”)
After a Salt & Light event earlier this year, one curious audience member asked a very good question: Is fair trade really making a difference?
If “making a difference” means whether a cacao or coffee planation worker in a poor nation working for a producer which sells gets its goods via fair trade channels receives a fair wage and benefits from investments in improvements and community projects that focus on better working and living conditions and sustainability, then the answer: YES (as supported by many studies).
There are exceptions. For example, a producer (i.e. the employer of the workers) who receives the fair trade minimum price may not pass on the profit to its workers as higher wages or invest profits into the community.
Some producers and workers will benefit more from fair trade than others, however that does not mean that fair trade is “not working”. For example, a small producer with unpredictable harvests and no budget to incur costs to place its own products in the global trade lines will benefit more from a minimum price compared to a larger producer with a predictable harvest and financial resources to directly market its goods to consumers. In some cases, direct subsidies and, where exploitation is occurring, enforcing the laws and prosecuting modern day slave masters may be a more efficient way of achieving "fairness".
There are exceptions. For example, a producer (i.e. the employer of the workers) who receives the fair trade minimum price may not pass on the profit to its workers as higher wages or invest profits into the community.
Some producers and workers will benefit more from fair trade than others, however that does not mean that fair trade is “not working”. For example, a small producer with unpredictable harvests and no budget to incur costs to place its own products in the global trade lines will benefit more from a minimum price compared to a larger producer with a predictable harvest and financial resources to directly market its goods to consumers. In some cases, direct subsidies and, where exploitation is occurring, enforcing the laws and prosecuting modern day slave masters may be a more efficient way of achieving "fairness".
Keep in mind that the concept of fair trade was not conceived to improve labor standards or cure social injustices, but rather it to give small farmers and producers direct access to global markets via cooperatives rather than having to rely on middle men (who take a cut of the profit, at the expense of the producers).
The issue which interests S&L most is: does fair trade makes a difference to human trafficking? (Click below to read more)

