A previous post posed: "Should Sweden's approach to prostitution be adopted everywhere?" That post identified the dangers of a world which legalised prostitution, which is the model adopted in Sweden and now in other countries.Recently in Dublin Amnesty International announced its plan to support a policy that calls for the decriminalisation of the sex trade. This means that pimps, brothel and buyers of sex can continue to go about their business unchecked.
Probably well intentioned, the plan comes from a view that the multi-billion dollar sex trade is a legitimate business that needs to protect sex workers (just like any people in danger or facing injustice) by supporting the legalisation of prostitution. In essence, by legalising it, the government could also (hope to) regulate. It is a big "could", and furthermore it comes from a hope that legalising prostitution would the rights and welfare of sex workers. But in reality, this policy will worsen the plight of child sex trafficking victims. Amnesty International's resolution can be found here. To be clear, Amnesty International opposes human trafficking.
Previously featured in the Spotlight series, Operation Underground Railroad (known as O.U.R), is an organization dedicated to rescuing children from sex slavery. Its CEO, Tim Ballard recently shared his passionate views about Amnesty International's plans, which can be found here. Below is an excerpt, but a good read of the entire article is recommended:
"Let’s break down this train of logic. In Amnesty’s resolution, “Draft Policy on Sex Work,” it argues that pimps and johns should be free from government interference and be permitted to exercise their autonomy. The argument is based on the idea that those being sold want to be sold, because it is their chosen profession. While certainly some have made that choice the idea dangerously ignores the backstory of those who “choose” prostitution. We must consider how many of these men and women were enslaved in the sex industry as children and now as adults who don’t see any other option. Is that a choice? We must also consider the enormous number of prostitutes that suffer from post-traumatic stress disorder and numerous sexually transmitted diseases. We must also acknowledge statistical confirmation that a disproportionate number of prostitutes are survivors of rape and child sex abuse. Do we really think that any of these men or women happily dreamed as children that one day they would grow up to sell their bodies for sex?"
Sex work (prostitution) and sex trafficking are two different things, and so long as law and policy maker and other organisations treat them similarly or alike, sex workers and human trafficking victims will continue to be left out. In the same way, Christian abolitionists need to see the differences so that they can minister to and pray for sex trafficking victims effectively.
Amnesty International fights to protect human rights and it has a good record of promoting gender equality, economic justice and corporate accountability but it is not a legal governing body. Nevertheless, the controversial policy is a marker of the growing swell of public opinion supporting the decriminalisation of sex work, which is itself is a liberal view of sin in the world.
Therefore, continue to pray that law and policy makers in Japan and around the world will continue to strengthen laws (rather than loosen them) and add to existing support services to help victims of human trafficking with wisdom and compassion.
If you so led by the Holy Spirit, you may also petition against Amnesty International policy by following this link, which was proposed by The Coalition Against Trafficking in Women (CATW). CATW's full open letter to Amnesty International can be found here.
No comments:
Post a Comment