Jesus followers@Tokyo Baptist Church & abolitionists of human trafficking in Japan & the world

Friday, 10 June 2016

Does “fair trade” work? (Part 2)

Part 1 covered how fair trade reduces human trafficking. Part 2 takes a deeper look at what you can do about it.

Fair trade is a market mechanism used to correct unfair markets. Markets are unfair because global competition drives retail prices down of cheaply produced goods down (like coffee and chocolate), which means that the demand for cheap labor increases. This demand (by producers) is fulfilled by cheap laborers whom are on the poverty line and willing to work at any price, or through traffickers who by force or deception illegally create slave labor work force which are imprisoned on farms and plantations. 

Fair trade “distorts” a free market that has a tendency for inequality so a more equitable outcome can be achieved. This equitable outcome is finally achieved when producers and farmers receive a sustainable wage for their labor and their communities and working conditions are enriched.

There has been at least one reported instance which this market mechanism has failed, however before joining critics who argue that it is evidence that fair trade "does not work", it should be remembered that:
  • Fair trade makes certain assumptions which may not hold true in every case, for example, that the fair trade employee actually pays higher wages gained from the minimum price to the worker. That is not the fault of fair trade, but that of the individual employer.
  • A fair trade label does not guarantee there is no child labor or human trafficking, however it is a significantly more reliable indicator that no child labor and human trafficking was in the supply of that good, compared to goods which cannot account for how it was made. 
From a biblical perspective, the world is deeply corrupted by sin, including its business practices (though not all). 
Indeed, there is no one on earth who is righteous, no one who does what is right and never sins. (Ecclesiastes 7:20)
Where corrupt actors within the supply chain of goods are able to make profit greedily at the expense of those unable to defend themselves, there will always be a tendency (or temptation) to act on that corrupt impulse, than to do the right thing. God continually warns against corruption:
The Lord detests differing weights, and dishonest scales do not please him. (Proverbs 20:23) 
“‘Do not defraud or rob your neighbour. ‘Do not hold back the wages of a hired worker overnight. (Leviticus 19:13) 
‘If you sell land to any of your own people or buy land from them, do not take advantage of each other. (Leviticus 25:14)


Fair trade is definitely a great idea. Your consumer choices make a difference. Promoting fair trade is just one of the ways you can both participate in and involve others in making choices which create fairer outcomes on those whom are most vulnerable to being exploited in making the goods that you consume. Consider doing some of the following:
  • Understand your sources. Understand the sources of the products you enjoy (or help produce at your workplace). In some cases, buying local or organic may be a viable option instead of cheaply priced mass produced imported products like chocolate and coffee. Check the website Products of Slavery that helps you understand which goods are most likely prodiuced by modern day slaves, so you make informed consumer decisions. Go to Slavery Footprint to determine which of your habits and purchases are most likely tied to human trafficking.
  • Embrace fair trade broadly. It is not just your consumer choices about chocolate, coffee, cotton and bananas, and fair trade is not only those products which have a fair trade logo. There are many alternative trade organizations that promote fairness in the supply of many different kinds of products. You can find some here and here  and here. Do you like coffee? Research direct trade companies like this and other kinds of logos, like the Rainforest Alliance (the one with the frog on it, here) which whilst, they don't show "fair trade" on products labels, promote and require that their certified farms comply with sustainability goals, including the fair treatment of its workers.

Tuesday, 7 June 2016

The UN's view on Japan

In September 2015, S&L sent a email to the mailing list informing of the official 7 day visit in Japan by Rapporteur Maud de Boer-Buquicchio who visited to assess the situation of the sale and sexual exploitation of children, including the production and sale of child abuse material in Japan. Ms. de Boer-Buquicchio is the independent expert mandated by the United Nations Human Rights Council to promote comprehensive strategies to prevent and combat the sale and sexual exploitation of children and to make recommendations for the care, recovery and reintegration of child victims.

At the press conference at the Japan National Press Club, she emphasised that Japan must stamp out the impunity granted to people who sexually exploit children, including light sentences and the reluctance to prosecute to overcome the nation’s “institutional” tolerance for such crimes. She said:
“Investigations and prosecutions are hardly ever initiated without a complaint lodged by the child victim. . . . The few cases that are prosecuted often end up with convictions that are suspended or entail low penalties, such as fines,” 
[In Japan,] “abusers and offenders can walk under the sun, while victims have to live in the shadows,”
 Other observations were:
  • The impunity enjoyed by sex offenders in Japan is “relatively high” compared with other developed nations, and the entrenched hesitation by police to take action struck her as “exceptional,” 
  • The low penalties that signify Japan’s “social and institutional tolerance” for related offenses, leaves victims susceptible to repeated exploitation.
  • The amendment to the child prostitution and pornography law in 2014 that criminalized private ownership of child abuse material was welcomed, but Japan can do more to tackle the situation, such as by outlawing online viewing of such material and banning manga with extreme child pornographic content
  • Regarding the JK business, aside from stiffening the penalties for sex offenders, Japan must implement a more “comprehensive strategy” to battle. She advised adopting measures such as increasing one-stop crisis centers, establishing complaint mechanisms for child victims and providing support for children with disabilities and young mothers.
Not all child sex exploitation is human trafficking however such child victims are highly vulnerable to being subsequently trafficked or they such children are trafficked into child pornography. 

Her findings and recommendations was submitted to the Human Rights Council of the U.N. in March. A summary of the offiical findings with respect to Japan will be posted shortly.

Wednesday, 1 June 2016

The Global Slavery Index 2016

Recently, the Walk Free Foundation published the The Global Slavery Index for 2016. The big picture is that almost 46 million people are trapped in modern-day slavery, two-thirds of them in the Asia-Pacific region. The study’s estimate of 45.8 million slaves worldwide is a rise of nearly 30 percent from a similar study done two years ago (see previous post here). The increase was attributed to better data collection.

Learn about Walk Free Foundation in our previous posts here and here.

Specifically concerning Japan (as reported in Japan times here and also reported here in Japanese), the study noted:
  • an estimated 290,200 people in Japan, or 0.23 percent of the population, are in slave-like servitude. This includes people trafficked for sex work or trapped in debt bondage and forced labor.
  • the involvement of organised crime in the Japanese sex industry with established ways of recruitment into source countries such as Thailand
  • long-standing allegations that a state-sponsored traineeship program locks foreign workers in unrewarding labor in Japanese industry and agriculture.
  • Japan is among the richest nations doing the least about the problem within its borders. It ranked Japan with Saudi Arabia, Qatar and South Korea.
  • modern-day slaves in Japan can expect about the same level of help as those in impoverished Myanmar and Tajikistan.
  • Japanese businesses are buying and selling raw materials and products from countries with extreme problems of labor slavery, such as Cambodia, Bangladesh and India.






Cybersex trafficking in the Philippines

A recent email from International Justice Mission contained the following praise point:
“Praise God for three cybersex trafficking rescue operations this week in the Philippines. During the three operations, the Philippines National Police rescued several very young girls and boys who were being sexually exploited over the internet. Please specially pray that the aftercare capacity in the Philippines will develop and expand quickly so that it can serve and accommodate for the young children who are taken out of these abusive situations and placed in reliable homes that can effectively care for them.”
 More details about IJM’s operation can be found here

What is cybersex trafficking? Basically, it is human trafficking + technology. Anyone who has a computer, internet, a webcam and vulnerable child/woman can be in the cybersex trafficking business. 

The child and woman “performs” live which is captured by the webcam and the customer or “john” can be anywhere in the world. 

The “cyber” word is used (short for cyberspace) because of this form of trafficking is facilitated by the internet. The “trafficking” word is used, because like other forms of trafficking, the victims sold and are forced or deceived into participating, for example by the promise of a good job to make money for themselves and their family. Once they are brought to big cities like Manila, they are sold time and time again by their traffickers to johns on their smartphone, tablet or laptop in their homes or hotels, anywhere in the world.

How did we get here? Technology makes anything easier these days, and crime is no exception. The Philippines like other South East Asian countries has high levels of poverty (and therefore more women and children at risk), high levels of internet access and technological literacy, and like most countries, laws which have not developed as fast as the technology leaving the vulnerable exposed. 

It is just as evil and harmful as other kinds of human trafficking, but it is mistakenly considered to be less serious by the sellers (typically, parents) because it may not even involve other people, and by the victims themselves, because the customer is not “real”. 

Because of the private nature of the crime and there are very low barriers for traffickers to establish a “cyber-den” and it is difficult for law enforcement to locate and prosecute (as usually, the authorities must catch the traffickers in the act).

For the buyer, it is considered low risk because of anonymity (i.e. it is easy for them to hide their identity). To give you an idea of how widespread it is, in 2013, a Dutch children’s rights organization created a virtual Filipino child victim using sophisticated computer modeling in an attempt to catch predators in the act. During a 10 week period, 20,000 people made approaches, 1000 predators were identified from 71 different countries. These predators were in fact not contacting a child, but engaging in online discussions and transactions with this organization which shared information with law enforcement authorities.   

Want to understand more about child sex abuse crimes? Read this 2015 report prepared by NetClean, which documents a significant increase in the volume of child sex abuse material being circulated online and increasing depravity.

What can you do about it?
  • Protect your own home from being a buyer or victim. Cybersex trafficking is more than just buying and selling. It is also a means of recruitment, advertising and getting business. It is not just popular social media like facebook, twitter or instagram but also chat rooms too.  The people in your home and communities can through making poor choices become a buyer or a victim. Maintain a healthy and transparent social media policy at home for your children. Place your own firewall on your home wifi router to block access to pornographic and sexually explicit material. Educate your family and community on how demand for pornography as a whole drives industries like human trafficking. In fact, buyers of cybersex trafficking are buyers of live interactive pornography. At home and in your communities, teach a biblical view on how God sees human trafficking, pornography and the abuse of women and children whom were created in His image. 
  • Pray. Join the mailing lists of organizations like International Justice Mission who update their activities in prosecuting cybersex traffickers and send prayer requests. The Philippines is not the only country which is renown for cybersex human trafficking. Pray that God would reveal to you the networks around you that are used to exploit the vulnerable and traffic women and children, and that those networks will fail.

Tuesday, 24 May 2016

Does “fair trade” work? (Part 1)


This is a 2 part series on fair trade. Part 1 addresses whether fair trade is making a difference and Part 2  contains suggestions on how you can participate.

(The term “fair trade” when used in this article refers to the model of trade which pays sustainable prices to workers and producers of goods, and not any specific organization or goods which are permitted to use certain labels, like “Fairtrade”)

After a Salt & Light event earlier this year, one curious audience member asked a very good question: Is fair trade really making a difference? 

If “making a difference” means whether a cacao or coffee planation worker in a poor nation working for a producer which sells gets its goods via fair trade channels receives a fair wage and benefits from investments in improvements and community projects that focus on better working and living conditions and sustainability, then the answer: YES (as supported by many studies). 

There are exceptions. For example, a producer (i.e. the employer of the workers) who receives the fair trade minimum price may not pass on the profit to its workers as higher wages or invest profits into the community. 

Some producers and workers will benefit more from fair trade than others, however that does not mean that fair trade is “not working”. For example, a small producer with unpredictable harvests and no budget to incur costs to place its own products in the global trade lines will benefit more from a minimum price compared to a larger producer with a predictable harvest and financial resources to directly market its goods to consumers. In some cases, direct subsidies and, where exploitation is occurring, enforcing the laws and prosecuting modern day slave masters may be a more efficient way of achieving "fairness". 

Keep in mind that the concept of fair trade was not conceived to improve labor standards or cure social injustices, but rather it to give small farmers and producers direct access to global markets via cooperatives rather than having to rely on middle men (who take a cut of the profit, at the expense of the producers). 

The issue which interests S&L most is: does fair trade makes a difference to human trafficking? (Click below to read more)

Sunday, 15 May 2016

The economics of human trafficking

Human trafficking is a complex issue. Economics and social factors certainly play a part in it. From a bibilcal perspective, its very existence evidences the spiritual condition of the world, i.e. the outcome of a fallen world caused by sin.


There seem to be 2 types of strategies for tackling the evil of human trafficking:
  • Demand side strategies: The thinking being, if people want it less, the supply of humans being trafficked for exploitative purposes (which has been illegally obtained by force or deception) will dry up. Examples are: advocating and enforcing tougher criminal laws on buyers (or "johns"), effective awareness campaigns, policies and education programmes designed to change harmful attitudes about women and children (for example, which are propagated by pornography) and employers engaged in businesses that are susceptible to using trafficked humans in their supply chains.
  • Supply side strategies: The thinking being, if the factors or conditions which lead to people being vulnerable to human trafficking can be identified (e.g. unemployment, poverty, weak legal systems, war), then mitigating those factors and conditions and if possible, preventing them, will nip trafficking trafficking at the bud. Examples are: advocating and enforcing tougher criminal laws on the sellers, education/rehabitliation programmes of potential and actual human trafficking victims, provision of community and welfare services to train and employ unskilled workers, protective services, rescue.
Japan's existing anti-trafficking initiatives have been critiqued in the latest 2015 Trafficking Persons Report. But there have been also other positive developments in Japan
There was NO evidence of human trafficking in both these instances, but they are indicative of efforts to stifle the demand and supply of child pornography, which feeds the demand for commercial sex. In general, many child victims of human trafficking are trafficked into child pornography.

Baylee Molloy, a research and writing fellow at the Institute of Faith, Work and Economics sums it quite well in her article here
We know that supply always responds to demand – so if we want the supply to go away then we have to take action to remove the demand. 
If we desire to see an illumination of human trafficking there will have to be a heart change on the part of those who demand trafficked humans. The power of the gospel must permeate their hearts to transform them from continuing on this evil path. 
While this is our hope, we know that this may not happen for all people and therefore we have to rely on our institutions that are put in place to protect. This is why rule of law, justice in the courts and property rights are so important. These elements increase the risk people are willing to take to harm others. 
As more people are educated about human trafficking, we will hopefully see greater penalties and prosecutions. 
The demand of trafficked individuals must be contained and put to an end by increasing the risks for perpetrators. 
In addition, the supply of trafficked individuals can be reduced by providing vulnerable populations with better economic opportunity and rule of law.

Saturday, 7 May 2016

Trafficking trends in Japan

As reported in the Asahi Shimbun
"Twenty-six foreigners were taken into protective custody in 2015 after becoming victims of human trafficking, including women forced to work at hostess bars through fraudulent or violent means", the Justice Ministry said.
  • By nationality, 17 were Filipinos, 8 were Thais and 1was Sri Lankan. 23 were women.
  • An increasing number of victims were Japanese-Filipino children born to Japanese men and Filipino women, or their mothers. In fact, the number of Japanese-Filipino children and their mothers who became victims of human trafficking has increased since legal revisions that took effect in 2009 made it possible for the children to obtain Japanese nationality if their fathers confirmed the biological ties. In as recent as February 2015, the operator of Philippine-themed nightclubs in Gifu Prefecture was found to have coerced the mothers of Japanese-Filipino children to work illegally in Japan.
  • According to Lighthouse (Center for Human Trafficking Victims), the number of inquiries it has handled about Japanese-Filipino children started to rise about 5 years ago. Many of these children or their mothers have been forced to work as hostesses, according to the NGO. Club operators have deducted “living expenses” from the women’s wages, leaving little money for their actual pay, and some of the women ended up working as prostitutes.
Update: On 20 May, Japan Times mentioned a government report citing different and bigger numbers:
  • A total of 54 people, including four males, were rescued from human trafficking (forced into prostitution and slavery) in Japan last year, up 29 from the previous year, a government report said Friday.
  • By nationality, the three largest were 30 Filipinos, followed by 13 Japanese and 10 Thais. The 4 males rescued had been victims of forced bondage.
  • The annual report was approved Friday during a meeting of Cabinet ministers called to discuss the prevention of human trafficking. This report, the second of its kind, was issued following the adoption of an action plan to fight human trafficking in December 2014 that called for the reinforcement of immigration controls and more support for trafficking victims.
  • “Human trafficking is not just a serious human rights violation, but also a significant international problem,” said Chief Cabinet Secretary Yoshihide Suga, who chaired the meeting at the Prime Minister’s Office. The meeting was attended by relevant ministers including Foreign Minister Fumio Kishida and National Public Safety Commission Chairman Taro Kono.