Jesus followers@Tokyo Baptist Church & abolitionists of human trafficking in Japan & the world

Tuesday, 24 May 2016

Does “fair trade” work? (Part 1)


This is a 2 part series on fair trade. Part 1 addresses whether fair trade is making a difference and Part 2  contains suggestions on how you can participate.

(The term “fair trade” when used in this article refers to the model of trade which pays sustainable prices to workers and producers of goods, and not any specific organization or goods which are permitted to use certain labels, like “Fairtrade”)

After a Salt & Light event earlier this year, one curious audience member asked a very good question: Is fair trade really making a difference? 

If “making a difference” means whether a cacao or coffee planation worker in a poor nation working for a producer which sells gets its goods via fair trade channels receives a fair wage and benefits from investments in improvements and community projects that focus on better working and living conditions and sustainability, then the answer: YES (as supported by many studies). 

There are exceptions. For example, a producer (i.e. the employer of the workers) who receives the fair trade minimum price may not pass on the profit to its workers as higher wages or invest profits into the community. 

Some producers and workers will benefit more from fair trade than others, however that does not mean that fair trade is “not working”. For example, a small producer with unpredictable harvests and no budget to incur costs to place its own products in the global trade lines will benefit more from a minimum price compared to a larger producer with a predictable harvest and financial resources to directly market its goods to consumers. In some cases, direct subsidies and, where exploitation is occurring, enforcing the laws and prosecuting modern day slave masters may be a more efficient way of achieving "fairness". 

Keep in mind that the concept of fair trade was not conceived to improve labor standards or cure social injustices, but rather it to give small farmers and producers direct access to global markets via cooperatives rather than having to rely on middle men (who take a cut of the profit, at the expense of the producers). 

The issue which interests S&L most is: does fair trade makes a difference to human trafficking? (Click below to read more)



The poor are especially vulnerable to exploitation by traffickers. As certain fair trade organizations require strict compliance with labor standards (for example, as part of the certification process to have the right to use a fair trade label), which include that there be no forced labor or child labor those producers are much less likely to use forced labor or child labor and by extension, human trafficking because the motivation for human trafficking is to illegally source cheap labour through exploitation. It is an indirect link, but it is there. 

Fair trade helps reduce human trafficking because when a producer is paid what he or she needs to live:
  • these producers can employ people in fair conditions to work on their farms;
  • worker's children can go to school instead of being needed to work on the farm;
  • social programs funded by fair trade subsidies, such as the Fairtrade premium (more information here) empower them workers to produce better and sustainable crops, creating a virtuous cycle. 
This kind of environment helps producers avoid the evil of demanding cheap labor by any means necessary and keeps the ones most susceptible to exploitation in better living conditions (especially children) and away from traffickers. 

Fair trade most likely would have prevented the exploitation of children uncovered in a 2000 investigative report by the BBC, involving the sale and purchase of hundreds of thousands of children from poverty stricken Mali, Burkina Faso, and Togo. These children were purchased by traffickers from their parents or stolen, and then shipped to the Ivory Coast, where they are sold as slaves to cocoa farms. After being trafficked, these children were put to work as slave labor in horrible working conditions which breach international laws on child labor (called the “worst forms of child labor”, which is defined here ).

Want to know more about the child slave trade and human trafficking in the chocolate industry? Follow this link: Child Slavery: The Bitter Truth behind the Chocolate Industry

Fair trade accounts for less than 1% of global trade ~ so, consuming fair trade goods alone will not rid the world of poverty and related issues like child labor and human trafficking, but it can certainly make a difference in reducing it. If more people buy fair trade products, the demand for “ethically sourced” product increases. And as demand rises, producers will begin to switch to fair trade standards and create better working conditions in order to meet the demand. And, this will ultimately reduce the demand for trafficking and exploitation and the number of people whom are vulnerable to trafficking.

No comments:

Post a Comment