Jesus followers@Tokyo Baptist Church & abolitionists of human trafficking in Japan & the world

Showing posts with label Fair trade. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Fair trade. Show all posts

Monday, 30 October 2017

Child Labor Report

The International Labour Organization (ILO) recently released a new Global Estimates of Child Labour Report.  152 million children all around the world are engaged in child labor, with much of that pertaining to human trafficking. The new global estimates are a collective effort from members of Alliance 8.7, the global partnership to end forced labor, modern slavery, human trafficking, and child labor. The webpage for the Report gives a great summary of the issue at hand today.

Child labor is internationally defined as work done by children that is too hazardous, demands long hours, or done by children who are too young. Estimates show that boys are more likely to be involved in labor than girls, but there are some activities that may not have been recorded. These children likely range from 5-17 years old with the majority of them working between 14 and 42 hour work weeks. The region most prone for having child labor is Africa, but Asia and the Pacific have the next greatest risk.

Alliance 8.7 has provided their methodology, Frequently Asked Questions, and their latest Report available for download as well. There is a hope of ending child labor by 2025, and the Report also addresses the progress on this goal.

What can be done? Even from across the world, we can be making a difference. As consumers, we can support fair trade which certifies the buying of products that are child labor free. There are several different labels that you can identify on different products such as food and clothing. These are a few that you can find:



To read more resources on this issue, there are websites such as www.wfto.com, www.acejapan.org, and www.ilo.org.


Prayer Points

Pray for the children of the world that are affected by child labor in its many different forms. Pray for their rescue.

Pray for this issue to come to light in more places and that Japan would be even more proactive to support fair trade.   

Friday, 10 June 2016

Does “fair trade” work? (Part 2)

Part 1 covered how fair trade reduces human trafficking. Part 2 takes a deeper look at what you can do about it.

Fair trade is a market mechanism used to correct unfair markets. Markets are unfair because global competition drives retail prices down of cheaply produced goods down (like coffee and chocolate), which means that the demand for cheap labor increases. This demand (by producers) is fulfilled by cheap laborers whom are on the poverty line and willing to work at any price, or through traffickers who by force or deception illegally create slave labor work force which are imprisoned on farms and plantations. 

Fair trade “distorts” a free market that has a tendency for inequality so a more equitable outcome can be achieved. This equitable outcome is finally achieved when producers and farmers receive a sustainable wage for their labor and their communities and working conditions are enriched.

There has been at least one reported instance which this market mechanism has failed, however before joining critics who argue that it is evidence that fair trade "does not work", it should be remembered that:
  • Fair trade makes certain assumptions which may not hold true in every case, for example, that the fair trade employee actually pays higher wages gained from the minimum price to the worker. That is not the fault of fair trade, but that of the individual employer.
  • A fair trade label does not guarantee there is no child labor or human trafficking, however it is a significantly more reliable indicator that no child labor and human trafficking was in the supply of that good, compared to goods which cannot account for how it was made. 
From a biblical perspective, the world is deeply corrupted by sin, including its business practices (though not all). 
Indeed, there is no one on earth who is righteous, no one who does what is right and never sins. (Ecclesiastes 7:20)
Where corrupt actors within the supply chain of goods are able to make profit greedily at the expense of those unable to defend themselves, there will always be a tendency (or temptation) to act on that corrupt impulse, than to do the right thing. God continually warns against corruption:
The Lord detests differing weights, and dishonest scales do not please him. (Proverbs 20:23) 
“‘Do not defraud or rob your neighbour. ‘Do not hold back the wages of a hired worker overnight. (Leviticus 19:13) 
‘If you sell land to any of your own people or buy land from them, do not take advantage of each other. (Leviticus 25:14)


Fair trade is definitely a great idea. Your consumer choices make a difference. Promoting fair trade is just one of the ways you can both participate in and involve others in making choices which create fairer outcomes on those whom are most vulnerable to being exploited in making the goods that you consume. Consider doing some of the following:
  • Understand your sources. Understand the sources of the products you enjoy (or help produce at your workplace). In some cases, buying local or organic may be a viable option instead of cheaply priced mass produced imported products like chocolate and coffee. Check the website Products of Slavery that helps you understand which goods are most likely prodiuced by modern day slaves, so you make informed consumer decisions. Go to Slavery Footprint to determine which of your habits and purchases are most likely tied to human trafficking.
  • Embrace fair trade broadly. It is not just your consumer choices about chocolate, coffee, cotton and bananas, and fair trade is not only those products which have a fair trade logo. There are many alternative trade organizations that promote fairness in the supply of many different kinds of products. You can find some here and here  and here. Do you like coffee? Research direct trade companies like this and other kinds of logos, like the Rainforest Alliance (the one with the frog on it, here) which whilst, they don't show "fair trade" on products labels, promote and require that their certified farms comply with sustainability goals, including the fair treatment of its workers.

Tuesday, 24 May 2016

Does “fair trade” work? (Part 1)


This is a 2 part series on fair trade. Part 1 addresses whether fair trade is making a difference and Part 2  contains suggestions on how you can participate.

(The term “fair trade” when used in this article refers to the model of trade which pays sustainable prices to workers and producers of goods, and not any specific organization or goods which are permitted to use certain labels, like “Fairtrade”)

After a Salt & Light event earlier this year, one curious audience member asked a very good question: Is fair trade really making a difference? 

If “making a difference” means whether a cacao or coffee planation worker in a poor nation working for a producer which sells gets its goods via fair trade channels receives a fair wage and benefits from investments in improvements and community projects that focus on better working and living conditions and sustainability, then the answer: YES (as supported by many studies). 

There are exceptions. For example, a producer (i.e. the employer of the workers) who receives the fair trade minimum price may not pass on the profit to its workers as higher wages or invest profits into the community. 

Some producers and workers will benefit more from fair trade than others, however that does not mean that fair trade is “not working”. For example, a small producer with unpredictable harvests and no budget to incur costs to place its own products in the global trade lines will benefit more from a minimum price compared to a larger producer with a predictable harvest and financial resources to directly market its goods to consumers. In some cases, direct subsidies and, where exploitation is occurring, enforcing the laws and prosecuting modern day slave masters may be a more efficient way of achieving "fairness". 

Keep in mind that the concept of fair trade was not conceived to improve labor standards or cure social injustices, but rather it to give small farmers and producers direct access to global markets via cooperatives rather than having to rely on middle men (who take a cut of the profit, at the expense of the producers). 

The issue which interests S&L most is: does fair trade makes a difference to human trafficking? (Click below to read more)

Tuesday, 27 January 2015

Why thinking before buying chocolate this Valentines Day matters..

(Updated 6th February) The chocolate you buy or eat this Valentines (or White) Day is a product of the cacao bean (or commonly called cocoa). 70% of the time, that cocoa would have been sourced from West Africa, and then sold to chocolate manufacturers around the world.

100,000s of children (aged 16 and under) labor in the West  Africa to produce cocoa, many of which work under the worst forms of child labour; a proportion of which are victims of human trafficking (i.e. forced labor) and slavery (i.e. work for no pay). Click here for more information on the human cost of chocolate, and also here. 

Cheap (slave) labour keeps costs down, and also the price of chocolate down (and this equally applies to  coffee). As a consumer what you buy can make a difference. Here is how...


Use the research of others: There are many organizations out there which have already researched the companies which source their cocao from slave free sources. For example, free2work rates companies across various industries based on their assessment of a company's supply chain and the Food Empowerment Project has a comprehensive list.
Buy certified products: If you don't have time to research, read the labels and look for third party certifications (like Fair Trade Logo, like the one to the right) which are used to confirm that the chocolate comes from a slave free supply chain. For example, chocolates which are certified by Fair Trade (Japan site) or chocolates which are produced by companies authorised to use the World Fair Trade Organisation mark (see below) on their products means that that workers are paid a fair wage, free from abusive and exploitative work practices and use environmentally substainable methods. 

As an example, the Fair Trade Japan website has listed some certified slave free chocolates here, here and here. 


Buy organic chocolate: Most (but not all) organic chocolate appears to be sourced in countries where, for the time being, slave or child labour has not been an issue. Organic chocolate is more scarce, which means producers tend to receive a fair price (and therefore producers have less incentives to exploit children and/or traffic them).


In case you you might be wondering...

Does buying Fair Trade certified chocolate guarantee that no child or slave labour was used in producing that chocolate?

No, at the moment it is impossible to guarantee that no child or slave labour was used in producing certified chocolate (even with Fair Trade's thorough assessment criteria and monitoring process), but certification means that action can be taken if child or slave labour is later discovered in the production of certified Fair Trade chocolate. For now it is the best assurance you can get. 

Are Fair Trade chocolates more expensive that non Fair Trade chocolates?
It depends. Although, there is little or no difference between Fair Trade chocolates and non Fair Trade chocolates, Fair Trade chocolates can be, but are not always, more expensive (but even so, how can you put a price on a Valentine? Or the life of a enslaved child?). Non Fair Trade chocolates are often traded by a long string of middlemen between the producer and the retailer, therefore increasing the price. Fair Trade chocolates tend to be based on direct trade relationships between the producer and the supplier, so that (theoretically) more of the price of the item goes directly to the Fair Trade producer.