Part 1 covered how fair trade reduces human trafficking. Part 2 takes a deeper look at what you can do about it.

Fair trade is a market mechanism used to correct unfair markets. Markets are unfair because global competition drives retail prices down of cheaply produced goods down (like coffee and chocolate), which means that the demand for cheap labor increases. This demand (by producers) is fulfilled by cheap laborers whom are on the poverty line and willing to work at any price, or through traffickers who by force or deception illegally create slave labor work force which are imprisoned on farms and plantations.
Fair trade “distorts” a free market that has a tendency for inequality so a more equitable outcome can be achieved. This equitable outcome is finally achieved when producers and farmers receive a sustainable wage for their labor and their communities and working conditions are enriched.
There has been at least one reported instance which this market mechanism has failed, however before joining critics who argue that it is evidence that fair trade "does not work", it should be remembered that:
- Fair trade makes certain assumptions which may not hold true in every case, for example, that the fair trade employee actually pays higher wages gained from the minimum price to the worker. That is not the fault of fair trade, but that of the individual employer.
- A fair trade label does not guarantee there is no child labor or human trafficking, however it is a significantly more reliable indicator that no child labor and human trafficking was in the supply of that good, compared to goods which cannot account for how it was made.
From a biblical perspective, the world is deeply corrupted by sin, including its business practices (though not all).
Indeed, there is no one on earth who is righteous, no one who does what is right and never sins. (Ecclesiastes 7:20)Where corrupt actors within the supply chain of goods are able to make profit greedily at the expense of those unable to defend themselves, there will always be a tendency (or temptation) to act on that corrupt impulse, than to do the right thing. God continually warns against corruption:
The Lord detests differing weights, and dishonest scales do not please him. (Proverbs 20:23)
“‘Do not defraud or rob your neighbour. ‘Do not hold back the wages of a hired worker overnight. (Leviticus 19:13)
‘If you sell land to any of your own people or buy land from them, do not take advantage of each other. (Leviticus 25:14)
Fair trade is definitely a great idea. Your consumer choices make a difference. Promoting fair trade is just one of the ways you can both participate in and involve others in making choices which create fairer outcomes on those whom are most vulnerable to being exploited in making the goods that you consume. Consider doing some of the following:
- Understand your sources. Understand the sources of the products you enjoy (or help produce at your workplace). In some cases, buying local or organic may be a viable option instead of cheaply priced mass produced imported products like chocolate and coffee. Check the website Products of Slavery that helps you understand which goods are most likely prodiuced by modern day slaves, so you make informed consumer decisions. Go to Slavery Footprint to determine which of your habits and purchases are most likely tied to human trafficking.
- Embrace fair trade broadly. It is not just your consumer choices about chocolate, coffee, cotton and bananas, and fair trade is not only those products which have a fair trade logo. There are many alternative trade organizations that promote fairness in the supply of many different kinds of products. You can find some here and here and here. Do you like coffee? Research direct trade companies like this and other kinds of logos, like the Rainforest Alliance (the one with the frog on it, here) which whilst, they don't show "fair trade" on products labels, promote and require that their certified farms comply with sustainability goals, including the fair treatment of its workers.
- Buy products made by rescued trafficked survivors: Like Agape International Missions (t-shirts and jewelry), Malia Designs (handbags and accessories), Good paper (greeting cards), Sari Bari (home décor, bags, blankets), Freeset (organic clothes) and Mulxiply (bags, leather goods, jewelry)
No comments:
Post a Comment